TP-Link TL-SG1428PE Review: The PoE Switch Behind 16 Cameras

Nobody walks into The Heritage Diner and asks about the network switch. They ask about the pancakes. Sixteen cameras watch over the dining room, the kitchen, the second floor and the lot outside, and every one of them runs back to a gray metal box on a high shelf in my office: a TP-Link TL-SG1428PE. It’s the least glamorous thing I bought for the camera project, and the one thing the whole system can’t live without.

Review – TP-Link TL-SG1428PE 24 Port Gigabit PoE Switch, NTTECH
Buy “TP-Link TL-SG1428PE” on Amazon

As an Amazon Associate I earn from qualifying purchases. A commission may be earned if you buy through this link, at no extra cost to you.

The Box at the End of Every Wire

Twenty-four powered ports, a 250-watt budget, and one job

I bought the switch on Amazon in January 2024, in the same order as the Synology recorder it feeds. The pairing matters. Cameras plug into the switch, the switch plugs into the recorder, and the recorder does the thinking. The switch’s job is plumbing.

Here’s what that plumbing is made of. TP-Link’s product page lists 24 gigabit PoE+ ports plus two copper and two SFP fiber uplinks, up to 30 watts on any single port and 250 watts across the whole box. The Omada spec page gives the standards as 802.3af and 802.3at, which covers nearly every PoE camera on the market, and the datasheet puts it at 17.3 by 8.7 by 1.7 inches, one rack unit tall. A Business Direct listing adds a switching capacity of 56 Gbps.

Numbers like that read like a menu nobody orders from. What they mean in a diner is simple: one cable to each camera, carrying both the picture and the power, and no electrician running an outlet to every corner of the ceiling.

Sixteen Lines, Two Floors and a Parking Lot

The switch was the easy part

The hard part was the wire. I had an IT guy run sixteen network cables through the building, across two floors and out around the perimeter. Ceilings came down. Walls got fished. Outside runs had to survive Long Island weather and the occasional delivery truck backing up too close. That was days of labor, and it’s where most of the money and patience went.

By comparison, the switch install was almost insulting. Set it on the shelf, plug in power, land sixteen cables in sixteen ports, run one cable to the recorder. TP-Link sells it as plug and play, and for a camera network that’s the truth. The cameras found power, the recorder found the cameras, and the gray box sat there blinking like it had been doing this for years.

The recorder gets its own review, and so do the Synology cameras. Because those cameras are Synology’s own, the recorder doesn’t charge a license per camera, which is half the reason the whole setup penciled out.

Doing the Power Math Before the Order

Sixteen cameras barely dent 250 watts

Every PoE buyer should do this arithmetic before clicking Buy. Dong Knows measured Synology’s TC500 camera at 4.8 watts. Sixteen of those come to about 77 watts. That leaves roughly two-thirds of the switch’s budget sitting unused, plus eight empty ports.

Two warnings about that math. The 250 watts is a shared pool, and each port caps at 30, so you can’t run 24 heavy devices at the top of their range at the same time. And cameras aren’t the only things that draw PoE. Pan-tilt-zoom units, cameras with heaters for outdoor winters, and Wi-Fi access points all pull more. Put every device on a spreadsheet, add them up, and leave headroom.

If you blow the budget anyway, the switch doesn’t just fall over. TP-Link’s product page says that when total draw passes 250 watts, it cuts power to lower-priority ports to keep the high-priority ones running. That’s a fuse box with judgment. You decide which cameras matter most, and the switch drops the rest first.

Scenarios I Plan Around

What the switch is built to do when something goes sideways

A camera system earns its keep on the bad nights, so these are the situations I set this up to handle. Some are what the switch promises on paper. All of them are the reason I wanted these features in the box rather than in my head.

A camera drops off the system. This one isn’t hypothetical. Cameras have dropped off on me more than once, and I still don’t know why. When it happens, I have to sign the camera back into the recorder by hand. Not a big deal on a slow afternoon. A real problem when it goes during a Sunday rush or overnight, because that’s exactly the stretch of footage you’ll want later and won’t have.

TP-Link’s Omada page describes PoE Auto Recovery: the switch notices when a powered device stops responding and cuts and restores its power to restart it. That handles a camera that hangs. It doesn’t diagnose why mine wander off, and it doesn’t sign a camera back into the recorder. Somebody still has to notice the black square and fix it. If your cameras drop, check the switch’s port status and cable diagnostics first, then the recorder’s logs, before blaming any one box.

I want to add a camera. I haven’t added or moved one since the install, but the room is there. With eight open ports and most of the power budget untouched, adding a camera is a cable run and a plug. The switch side of that job takes a minute. The cable side still takes a guy and a ladder.

Somebody plugs a laptop into a camera port. It happens in any business with more than one person who thinks they understand computers. The TP-Link page says the switch checks what’s connected and only sends power to devices that ask for it, so a laptop or a printer gets a network connection and nothing that would fry it.

The cameras and the office share a wire. If I ever hang the office computer or a printer off this switch, the camera traffic shouldn’t get choked by someone downloading a menu PDF. TP-Link lists a priority mode built to protect video monitoring traffic, along with QoS and support for up to 32 VLANs, so cameras can live on their own lane.

The office gets hot in July. Mine sits high on a shelf, and heat rises. Equipment in a restaurant rarely gets a cooled server room. It goes wherever the wires happen to end. The datasheet lists an operating range up to 50°C, or 122°F, and two internal fans. If the shelf ever pushes that, the fix is airflow, not a new switch.

What Owners Say, Fans and All

The common complaint is noise

Owners who post about this switch mostly agree it does the job. The complaint that keeps coming back is the fan. One buyer, quoted on a reseller’s review page, said the fan can be noticeably loud in quiet rooms and suggested a garage, utility closet or network cabinet. Another, on a mirror of the same listing, took off a star because the switch sits in a sound booth where people work.

TP-Link’s own datasheet backs them up with numbers: 35.5 dBA at the quiet end and 47.8 dBA at full tilt, measured from half a meter. Mine sits on a shelf in my office, and I can hear it slightly. Nothing bad. In a restaurant, with a hood fan and a dish machine going on the other side of the wall, it disappears. In a recording booth or a silent bedroom, I’d understand the complaint.

Warranty is the other thing to check. A review roundup flags that some product titles say limited lifetime while the support terms describe three years. Confirm with TP-Link before you count on either.

Where It Falls Short

It moves traffic. It doesn’t route it.

This is a Layer 2 switch. It can split the network into VLANs, but it can’t route between them, so anything fancier needs a router or a Layer 3 device on top. TP-Link calls the tier “Easy Smart,” which sits between a dumb switch and a fully managed one, and retailers can’t agree on what to call it. One eBay listing says managed and another retailer says unmanaged. Both are half right.

Here’s the honest turn. I spent real money on the recorder for its AI search and real money on the cameras for their picture, and I treated this switch like an extension cord. That was backwards. If the switch dies, every camera goes dark at once, and the smartest recorder in the world is watching sixteen black squares. It’s the cheapest box in the stack and the only single point of failure. If I were doing it again, I’d keep a spare on the shelf, or at least know exactly where to buy one the same day.

Price, and Who It’s For

At the time of writing, eBay listings ran from about $196 to $275, and efive listed it at $275.99. Prices move, so check the current number before you buy.

I’d recommend it to any small business putting in eight to twenty PoE cameras, a few access points or a bank of IP phones, with somewhere to put a box that hums a little. If your closet is silent and your budget is tight, look at a smaller fanless switch. If you need routing, buy a router.

  • TP-Link TL-SG1428PE: the 24-port PoE+ Easy Smart switch running my diner’s cameras. See it on Amazon (affiliate link)

I run The Heritage Diner, where this switch is installed. The Amazon link above is an affiliate link.

Sources

You Might Also Like