Twenty-five dollars and sixty-eight cents. That is Etsy’s 6.5 percent transaction fee on a $395 handmade leather bag, and from October 20, 2026 through January 4, 2027 Etsy will hand the whole thing back on any order a seller drives through a Share & Save link. The catch sits in the same terms: if the buyer’s last click before buying was an Etsy Offsite Ad, the refund disappears and a 15 percent ad fee lands on the order instead, which on that bag is $59.25.
What Etsy is refunding until January 4
Share & Save is Etsy’s program for sellers who bring their own traffic. A seller gets tracked links to the shop or to listings, posts them outside Etsy, and earns a fee refund on qualifying orders. Under the standing Share & Save program terms, that refund is “four (4) percent of the Qualifying Transaction Total,” and the purchase has to happen within thirty days of the buyer clicking the link.
For the holidays Etsy raised the refund to the full fee. Its announcement to sellers promises zero transaction fees on eligible orders driven through Share & Save links and says the 6.5% refund “only applies through January 4, 2027, after which the refund will be 4%.” Sellers already enrolled get it automatically. Value Added Resource reported the qualifying window as orders completed between October 20, 2026 and January 4, 2027, with the buyer’s click inside the same window, and noted that payment processing, listing fees and other charges still apply.
So the promotion is a fee holiday on one line of the invoice, not on the whole invoice. The other lines keep running, the way a cab meter runs while the cab sits at the curb.
One $395 order, five ways
The table below prices a single $395 order under each case. The example assumes free shipping built into the price, one $0.20 listing fee, and no sales tax in the processing base; in a real order, shipping charged to the buyer adds to the transaction fee base and tax adds to the processing base. Rates come from Etsy’s Fees & Payments Policy (6.5% transaction fee on the item price plus shipping and gift wrap, $0.20 listing fee, Offsite Ads at 15% or 12% with a $100 cap per order) and Etsy Payments (3% plus $0.25 for U.S. bank accounts, on the gross order amount).
| Case | Transaction fee | Refund | Offsite Ads fee | Processing + listing | Total Etsy fees | Share of $395 |
|---|---|---|---|---|---|---|
| Buyer found it on Etsy, no link | $25.68 | $0 | $0 | $12.30 | $37.98 | 9.6% |
| Share & Save, holiday window | $25.68 | $25.68 | $0 | $12.30 | $12.30 | 3.1% |
| Share & Save, after January 4 | $25.68 | $15.80 | $0 | $12.30 | $22.18 | 5.6% |
| Offsite Ad was the last click, 15% shop | $25.68 | $0 | $59.25 | $12.30 | $97.23 | 24.6% |
| Offsite Ad was the last click, 12% shop | $25.68 | $0 | $47.40 | $12.30 | $85.38 | 21.6% |
The spread between the best and worst rows is $84.93 on one bag. That is more than the holiday refund three times over, and it turns on a click that happens out of the seller’s sight.

The $100 cap on Offsite Ads only starts to bite above $666.67 at the 15 percent rate, or $833.33 at 12 percent. A $395 order sits well under either line, so the full percentage applies. For a maker whose prices run in the mid-hundreds, this is the worst part of the curve: big enough for the percentage to hurt, too small for the cap to help.
The click that cancels the refund
Offsite Ads are Etsy’s promotions of a seller’s listings on search engines, social media and partner sites, and a shop pays only when a buyer clicks one and buys within 30 days. The program terms tie the two systems together in one sentence: if a buyer clicks a Share & Save link and later buys through an Offsite Ad within the attribution window, “the transaction is not a Qualifying Transaction and you may be charged the Offsite Ads fee for that transaction.” Value Added Resource described the same collision in dollar terms: the seller can lose the Share & Save refund and pay a 12 or 15 percent ad fee on top of the regular transaction fee. Alura’s summary of the holiday offer put it more bluntly: an order “doesn’t count if the buyer’s last click before buying was an Offsite Ad.”
Some sellers can step out of the way. Etsy’s help page on how Offsite Ads work says a shop that has never made $10,000 or more in any consecutive 365-day period can opt out. A shop that crosses that line is enrolled “for the lifetime of your shop,” at the lower 12 percent rate. The sellers most likely to run a real Share & Save campaign, the ones with enough buyers to bother, are the ones who can’t turn the ads off.
The two clocks run the same length. Share & Save counts thirty days from the seller’s link, and the help page counts thirty days from Etsy’s ad, so a single buyer can sit inside both windows at once while the terms settle the tie in the ad’s favor. On the numbers above, one 15 percent ad fee on the bag ($59.25) eats the holiday refund on about 2.3 other bags.
For a shop still under the $10,000 line, opting out of Offsite Ads for the season removes the collision entirely. The price is whatever sales those ads would have found without the seller’s help, and that trade can only be judged from the shop’s own order history, ad-attributed orders on one side and Share & Save orders on the other.
A holiday buyer who sees a bag on Instagram, clicks the seller’s link, thinks about it for a week, then clicks an Etsy ad for the same bag on a search page before paying, has just moved the order from the 3.1 percent row to the 24.6 percent row. Nothing about the bag changed. The seller found the buyer, and the ad that showed up a week later took the credit at the highest rate on the table.
Where the links can go, and where they can’t
The program terms say links “may not be shared or linked on the Etsy platforms, including the Etsy mobile apps,” and that orders from links shared anywhere other than authorized channels don’t qualify. Alura’s write-up named two traps directly: links “sent through Etsy Messages or placed in listing descriptions don’t count either.” A seller answering a buyer’s question inside Etsy with a helpful Share & Save link has handed over a link that earns nothing.
What’s left are the places a small shop already talks to buyers on its own: an email list, social posts, a personal website. The links are tracked, much like the tagged links in the post on UTM tracking. Etsy keeps the scoreboard, and Etsy decides which click gets credit when two of them point at the same sale. A seller who already sends a December email can swap the plain listing URLs for Share & Save URLs and lose nothing.

The argument for skipping Etsy altogether
Plenty of sellers look at Share & Save and ask a blunt question: if the seller is doing the work of finding the buyer, why send that buyer to Etsy at all? Value Added Resource pointed back to that older argument, which it framed as whether promoting Etsy listings beats sending buyers to the seller’s own website. A buyer who lands on an owned shop pays no Etsy fee, never sees an Offsite Ad attribution, and ends up on the seller’s customer list rather than on the marketplace’s.
It is a good argument, and the holiday promotion weakens it only a little. During the window, the Etsy-side cost of a Share & Save order on the $395 bag is $12.30, almost all of it card processing that an owned site would pay to its own processor anyway. The difference between Etsy and a standalone store in December is mostly not the fee. It is everything else: who holds the buyer’s email, whose checkout the buyer trusts, and whose ads might grab the last click. Those trade-offs are laid out at length in Etsy or your own shop for handmade goods, and the holiday calendar side of it in planning the holiday quarter.
After January 4 the refund drops to 4 percent, and the same order costs $22.18 in Etsy fees with a link and $37.98 without one. Share & Save keeps paying something after the holidays. The Offsite Ads override keeps working too, at the same 12 or 15 percent, in every month of the year.
The seam at January 4
The promotion ends in the middle of a thirty-day clock. Share & Save gives a buyer thirty days from the click to buy. A December 28 click is still good on January 20. Value Added Resource reported that the regular refund resumes January 4 at 9 a.m. Eastern. Alura wrote that it did not know which rate applies when a buyer clicks a link on or before January 4 and orders after it, and Etsy’s announcement doesn’t say.

For the $395 bag, the gap between the two answers is $9.88, which is small on one order and less small across a January of gift-card buyers and late shoppers who clicked before New Year’s. Sellers who have already had a Share & Save order straddle the date are the only ones who can answer it, and the comments below are open for the statement line that shows which refund Etsy paid.
For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney or financial advisor.
Sources
- Etsy Community, “Our Share & Save holiday gift to you”
- Etsy, Share & Save Program Terms
- Etsy, Fees & Payments Policy
- Etsy, Payments Policy
- Etsy Help, How Etsy’s Offsite Ads Work
- Value Added Resource, “Etsy Offers 0% Share & Save Transaction Fees For Holiday Shopping Season”
- Alura, Share & Save holiday refund
