A maker choosing between Etsy and a shop of their own is choosing who owns the counter. On Etsy the counter belongs to Etsy, and the maker rents a spot at it. On a site of the maker’s own, the counter belongs to the maker, along with the lease, the lighting and the job of getting people through the door. Everything below about Etsy comes from Etsy’s own pages and other official ones, linked where used.
What Etsy says the arrangement is
The rules come with the foot traffic
Etsy’s page for new sellers describes how a shop opens: create an account, set a location and currency, choose a shop name, create a listing, and set up payment and billing. Sellers decide what they sell, within Etsy’s rules, along with their pricing, shipping charges, sales and coupons. Etsy says funds from sales go to the seller’s bank account, and that eligible Etsy Payments purchases are covered by Etsy Purchase Protection, under which Etsy refunds buyers for qualifying damaged or undelivered orders and sellers keep their earnings.
The fee structure on that page has several parts. There is a listing fee, a transaction fee on the sale price, a payment processing fee when the seller accepts payments through Etsy Payments, a fee on sales that come through Etsy’s Offsite Ads, and a currency conversion fee when the shop’s listing currency differs from the payment account’s currency. It also says a one-time shop set-up fee may be charged and that there are no additional monthly fees. The page gives figures for each. They are left out on purpose, because fee tables are changed by the platform and a number printed here would be stale the day Etsy edits its page. Read the current page before doing any math, and do the math on your own prices, not on an average.
What matters more than any single fee is the shape of it. The costs attach to events: a listing going up, an item selling, a sale arriving by a certain route. That is different from a monthly rent. A shop with few sales pays little, and a shop with many pays more in total. Whether that suits a maker depends on how many pieces they sell and what each one earns, and that is arithmetic only the maker can do.
What Etsy requires of the maker

Made, designed, handpicked or sourced, and no mailing list
Etsy’s Seller Policy says “everything listed for sale on Etsy must be made, designed, handpicked, or sourced by a seller.” For a maker of handmade goods that is the point of the place. A shop that sells things the maker did not make or choose does not belong there, and the policy says so.
The part that surprises people is about customers. Section 2b of the same policy says “Without the buyer’s consent… you may not add any Etsy member to your email or physical mailing list.” It adds that “This information may only be used for Etsy-related communications or for Etsy-facilitated transactions.” A buyer who purchases a briefcase, a wallet or a set of coasters on Etsy is Etsy’s contact first. The seller can write to them about their order. They cannot, without that buyer’s consent, put them on a newsletter list.
That one sentence is most of the argument for the other side of the ledger. A maker who wants a list of past customers to tell about a new run of work has to build that list somewhere Etsy’s rules do not cover. The mechanics of that are covered in email list from zero, and the point there stands whichever way a maker sells: a list is built from people who agreed to be on it.
The policy also puts legal compliance on the seller: “you are responsible for complying with all applicable laws and regulations.” And it requires that orders shipped to the United States use a Delivery Duty Paid shipping method, which is worth reading in full by anyone shipping across a border.
Sales tax: the marketplace collects, and you still have homework

A marketplace can collect tax for you and not remove your obligations
The New York State Department of Taxation and Finance explains this on its page about sales tax requirements for marketplace providers. A marketplace provider, in its words, is “a person who agrees to facilitate sales for a marketplace seller.” Marketplace providers must collect New York State and local sales tax on taxable sales of tangible personal property they facilitate that occur in New York State or are delivered to a New York State address.
That sounds like the end of the topic, and the same page says it is not. A seller who is still required to register must still apply for a Certificate of Authority, and the page’s answer to whether that applies even when the marketplace collects tax is a plain “Yes.” Registered sellers also stay responsible for collecting tax on in-state sales and taxable transactions the provider did not facilitate. They report marketplace-facilitated sales on their periodic sales tax returns as nontaxable sales and keep the related records.
Put into a maker’s week, a shop that sells through a marketplace and also from its own site ends up with two kinds of sales to keep separate: the ones the marketplace handled, and the ones the maker handled alone. That bookkeeping is the same work whether the sales channel is Etsy or any other. An accountant who handles New York sales tax should look at it before the first sale, not after the first return is due. No claim is made here about which of these rules apply to a particular shop, because that turns on facts about the shop that are not known here.
What you carry on your own site
Nobody else is holding up the shelf
On a site of its own, a shop pays for what it uses and answers for everything it says. The platform does not provide the arrival of customers, either. Etsy’s pitch is that people are already looking for things in its store. A new domain has to earn that, through search, through social posts, through a list and through word of mouth. The sources used for this post do not measure how much traffic either channel produces, and no comparison is invented. What can be said is that the two options cost different things in different currencies: one in fees per sale, the other in the time spent being found.
For a comparison of the build-your-own options, Shopify or WooCommerce for a small shop goes through the choices.
One rule applies to both channels. The Federal Trade Commission’s guide to the Mail, Internet, or Telephone Order Merchandise Rule covers sellers of merchandise ordered by mail, internet or telephone. If a seller states a shipping time, the seller must have a reasonable basis to ship within it. If no time is stated, the seller needs a reasonable basis to believe it can ship within 30 days of getting a properly completed order. When a delay is coming, the seller has to get the customer’s consent to the delay or cancel and refund promptly. A handmade product with a long make time makes that rule more relevant, not less. A listing that says “ships in a few days” for a piece that takes weeks is a problem on any platform.
Using both

One channel does not rule out the other
Nothing in the sources forbids a maker from selling on Etsy and from a site of their own. The Seller Policy limits what an Etsy seller can do with Etsy buyers’ information. It does not say a seller cannot have another store. The practical shape is a split of jobs. A marketplace shop can be where people who are already searching find the work. A site of the maker’s own can be where the maker’s pages, process, policies and mailing list live, with the list built from people who chose to join.
There is a catch, and it is the honest turn against the case for keeping both. Two shops are two sets of listings, two sets of photos to keep matching, two inventories to reconcile and two places where a price can go stale. Anyone who has kept a menu in more than one place knows how that ends: a Google Business Profile can keep showing old menu prices because the menus were updated by hand and one place got missed, and people call to order from the old menu. A maker with a single workbench and a single stock of finished pieces needs a single source of truth for what is for sale.
For the choice between selling online at all and selling at fairs, craft fairs or online first takes up the earlier question.
For informational purposes only; fee schedules and platform policies change, so read Etsy’s current pages before deciding. Questions about sales tax registration, collection and reporting belong with a licensed accountant or attorney who knows New York sales tax.
Sources
- Etsy, Sell on Etsy: https://www.etsy.com/sell
- Etsy, Seller Policy: https://www.etsy.com/legal/sellers
- New York State Department of Taxation and Finance, Sales tax requirements for marketplace providers: https://www.tax.ny.gov/pubs_and_bulls/publications/sales/marketplace.htm
- Federal Trade Commission, Business Guide to the Mail, Internet, or Telephone Order Merchandise Rule: https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/business-guide-ftcs-mail-internet-or-telephone-order-merchandise-rule
- Cayce Anne, Etsy VS Your Own Website: Which Is Right For You? (YouTube): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=5qNusT9oILM
- Till Post, email list from zero: https://tillpost.com/email-list-from-zero/
- Till Post, Shopify or WooCommerce for a small shop: https://tillpost.com/shopify-or-woocommerce-small-shop/
- Till Post, craft fairs or online first: https://tillpost.com/craft-fairs-or-online-first/
