The first email a new subscriber gets is the only one that is certain to be opened with some curiosity, because the person just asked for it. Whatever it says, it is read by someone who was on a sign-up form a minute ago and wondering what they signed up for. No welcome email series is reported on here, so this post does not describe how one performed. It collects what email-service providers, the Federal Trade Commission and a video from an email marketer say about the job, with each source linked where it is used.
Send it right away
The timing is the first part of the message
Mailjet’s email playbook page on welcome emails is plain about the timing: “For the first welcome email, you want to send it as soon as the user signs up.” Constant Contact’s guide to writing a welcome email says the same thing from the other direction. Send the welcome email automatically right after someone joins your list, and it lists sending nothing after the signup among the mistakes to avoid.
The reason is practical. A person who signed up at a counter, on a website or at a fair has just done something and expects an answer. An email that arrives the next afternoon is arriving to a person who has already moved on. One that arrives within a minute confirms that the thing worked, and it does so while the shop’s name still means something.
That means the email has to send itself. Mailchimp’s help page on automated welcome messages explains that every welcome flow starts with a sign-up trigger, either “Signs up for Email” or “Signs up for SMS,” and that the trigger enrolls contacts who are new to the audience and subscribed. A few details on that page matter if a list already exists. Imported contacts are included by default, but the flow has a checkbox to exclude them. Contacts from a one-time historical sync are skipped, so existing customers do not all get a welcome message at once. With double opt-in, contacts enter the flow only after confirming their subscription. Already-subscribed contacts are not added again.
Those behaviors are specific to that service, and other services work differently. The general lesson holds anywhere: before turning the flow on, find out whether it will send to the people already on the list, because a welcome email addressed to a customer of five years is an odd thing to receive. The common tools are compared in free email marketing tools compared, and every one of them is worth checking on this point.
What goes in it

One reason for writing, a short body, one next step
Constant Contact’s guide gives a list of what the body can contain. Thank the subscriber for joining and say why you are emailing. Keep the body short. Add social proof, such as links to social accounts and a testimonial or two. Offer a welcome gift or discount code, which it notes can match the incentive used to collect the address and lets the sender track conversions. Introduce the mission. Set expectations for how often you will email and what the emails will cover. Offer help with direct links to support. Include a clear call to action. And make unsubscribing easy and visible.
That is ten items, and nobody needs all ten in one email. Mailjet’s page is shorter: gratitude, a brand introduction, an incentive, social links and clear calls to action. It adds that the content should be relevant and brief, and that a welcome can be one email or a sequence of three to five. In its words, “you may choose one email or an email sequence of 3–5 welcome emails to send.”
For a small shop or a restaurant, the useful move is to choose from the list, not to use all of it. A working version has four parts:
- A line of thanks that says what the person signed up for.
- A sentence or two about who is writing and what the business makes or serves.
- What will come next and how often, so the second email does not feel like a surprise.
- One button or link: the menu, the shop, the page the person most likely wants.
The “how often” line is the one most owners skip, and it is the one that does the most work. Constant Contact’s guide includes setting expectations for frequency and content among its recommendations, and it recommends planning a 3 to 6 month editorial calendar so there is something to send after the welcome. A promise to send a note on the first of the month is worth making only if the first of the month has a note in the drafts.
The subject line and the greeting

Short, warm and accurate
Constant Contact’s guidance on the subject line is to keep it short, warm and accurate, avoid sales pitches and clickbait, and use at most one exclamation point. Its example is “Welcome to Evolve with Krystal!”
The FTC says something similar from a legal angle. Its CAN-SPAM compliance guide for business states that the subject line “must accurately reflect the content of the message.” Anyone tempted to dress up a welcome email with a subject line promising a prize that the body does not deliver should read that sentence first.
On greeting a person by name, the Constant Contact guide advises asking for a first name in the sign-up form but not making it required, because people may enter nonsense. It also suggests setting a fallback greeting for when the name is missing. A form with one field, the email address, sends fewer bad greetings than a form with five fields and a required first name that half of the readers filled in with a keystroke test.
The video embedded above is from an email marketer, Kasey Luck, who walks through good and bad examples. It was not watched in full, and no claim from it is cited. It is there because seeing a few real welcome emails side by side teaches more than a description of them does.
What the law says about it
A welcome email is usually a marketing email
The FTC’s guide lists the main requirements of the CAN-SPAM Act, and they apply to commercial email, including email to existing customers. The guide’s example of a covered message is a message to former customers announcing a new product line. The requirements the guide describes include:
- Header information, such as “From,” “To” and “Reply-To,” must be accurate and identify the person or business that sent the message.
- The subject line cannot be deceptive.
- The message must be clearly and conspicuously identified as an advertisement, though the law allows flexibility in how.
- It must include a valid physical postal address, such as a current street address, a registered PO box or a registered private mailbox.
- It must explain clearly how to opt out of future marketing email, and the sender must honor opt-out requests within 10 business days, with the mechanism working for at least 30 days after sending.
- Hiring another company to send the email does not transfer the legal responsibility.
The guide also describes a narrow exemption. Messages whose primary purpose is transactional or relationship content, such as confirming an agreed transaction, are exempt from most provisions. The guide warns against assuming that a message to someone with an ongoing commercial relationship is automatically exempt. If the primary purpose of the message is commercial, the full requirements apply.
A welcome email that thanks a person and also offers a discount, a link to the shop and a call to buy is, on its face, mixing purposes, and arguing it into the exemption would be a stretch. Put the address and the unsubscribe link in, which is also what the email-service providers’ templates do. Whether a specific email falls on one side of the line or the other is a question for an attorney.
Test it before it is live

Sign up as a stranger
Mailchimp’s page suggests a step that is easy to skip. You can send test emails to check design, copy and links without activating the flow. After turning the flow on, verify that it is active and run a test signup, using an address that has not subscribed or entered the flow before, since previously used addresses will not receive the email again. It suggests Gmail plus-addressing, such as name+1@gmail.com, for making test addresses.
That advice is about one service, but the habit carries over. Sign up the way a customer would, on a phone, from the page where the form actually lives, and read what arrives. Check that the thanks line reads right with and without a name, that the link goes to the page you meant, and that the unsubscribe link works. Where the sign-up came from a paper sheet at the counter, as in collecting email addresses at the counter, check that the welcome email makes sense to a person who wrote their address on a clipboard and has no memory of the website.
The Mailjet page reports a 50% average open rate for welcome emails and says that is 86% more effective than standard newsletters. That is reported as Mailjet’s claim, not as an independent measurement, since the page does not say what data it comes from. Even taken at face value, a high open rate belongs to the sender who had a sign-up reason behind it. The email still has to be worth reading.
For informational purposes only; email laws and platform features change, so check the current FTC guide and your provider’s help pages. For questions about whether a specific email complies with CAN-SPAM, consult a licensed attorney.
Sources
- Mailjet, Onboard new subscribers with welcome emails: https://www.mailjet.com/email-playbook/lifecycle/welcome-emails/
- Constant Contact, How to Write a Welcome Email: https://www.constantcontact.com/blog/welcome-email/
- Mailchimp, About automated welcome messages: https://mailchimp.com/en-au/help/create-an-automated-welcome-email/
- Federal Trade Commission, CAN-SPAM Act: A Compliance Guide for Business: https://www.ftc.gov/business-guidance/resources/can-spam-act-compliance-guide-business
- Kasey Luck, How to write a perfect welcome email. Good & bad welcome emails examples (YouTube): https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gJ5BEg4_PAU
- Till Post, free email marketing tools compared: https://tillpost.com/free-email-marketing-tools-compared/
- Till Post, collecting email addresses at the counter: https://tillpost.com/collecting-email-addresses-at-counter/
