Three systems cover most of the small-restaurant POS market in the United States: Square, Toast and Clover. Each publishes some pricing and withholds the rest, and each bundles card processing in a different way, so a comparison of sticker prices alone misleads. The figures below come from the vendors’ own pricing pages and from NerdWallet’s independent reviews, all read at the time of writing, and every rate or fee may have changed since.
Monthly software fees as listed
Square’s restaurant pricing page lists three plans per location: Square Free at $0 a month, Square Plus at $49 and Square Premium at $149. A fourth tier, Square Pro, applies to businesses that process more than $250,000 a year and carries custom pricing. Kitchen display software is billed per device: $30 a month on Plus and $20 on Premium, and unavailable on Free.
Toast’s pricing guide lists a Starter Kit that starts at $0 a month for software, a Point of Sale plan from $69 a month that includes the first hardware terminal subscription, and a custom Build Your Own plan. The Starter Kit is limited to new customers and single locations.
Clover’s quick-service pricing page shows the Restaurant Growth software plan at $89.95 a month on its Starter and Standard tiers and $109.90 on Advanced. Hardware is priced separately, from $849 for a Mini or $1,899 for a Station Duo, or as monthly payments over 36 months. NerdWallet’s Clover review adds full-service tiers at $89.95, $109.90 and $129.85.
The headline difference is clear: Square and Toast each offer a $0 software tier, and Clover’s listed restaurant plans start near $90. A $0 plan does not mean low cost, because the processing rate on the cheap tier is where each vendor recovers its money.
Card processing rates
Square’s page shows in-person rates of 2.6% + 15¢ on Free, 2.5% + 15¢ on Plus and 2.4% + 15¢ on Premium, with online payments at 3.3% + 30¢ on Free and 2.9% + 30¢ on the other two. Keyed-in or card-on-file payments are 3.5% + 15¢.
Toast does not print rates on its pricing page, which describes the company as a payment facilitator and says rates vary by plan. NerdWallet’s Toast review reports pay-as-you-go processing at 3.09% + $0.15 and card-present processing at 2.49% + $0.15 on the upfront-hardware route. Those are the reviewer’s numbers, so a written quote is the only authoritative source.
Clover’s page shows 2.3% + 10¢ for tapped, swiped or inserted cards on every quick-service tier and 3.5% + 10¢ for keyed-in payments. NerdWallet notes that the rates assume Fiserv as the processor.
A worked comparison
Two assumptions drive the next figures: $20,000 of monthly in-person card sales and 800 transactions, an average ticket of $25. Both are invented for illustration. Percentage fees plus per-transaction cents plus the monthly software fee come to the following, with hardware and add-ons excluded:
- Square Free: $520 + $120 = $640
- Square Plus: $500 + $120 + $49 = $669
- Square Premium: $480 + $120 + $149 = $749
- Clover (quick-service rate and software fee): $460 + $80 + $89.95 = $629.95
- Toast upfront-hardware route: $498 + $120 + $69 = $687
- Toast pay-as-you-go: $618 + $120 + $0 = $738
At that volume the free Square tier beats Plus and Premium, because a 0.1 percentage point saving on $20,000 is only $20 a month against a $49 fee. Moving to Plus pays off past roughly $49,000 in monthly card sales ($49 divided by 0.1%), and Premium over Plus past roughly $100,000. At $50,000 and 2,000 transactions, the same arithmetic gives $1,600 for Square Free, $1,599 for Plus, $1,649 for Premium, $1,439.95 for Clover, $1,614 for Toast’s upfront route and $1,845 for Toast pay-as-you-go. The figures are arithmetic on published or reported rates, not quotes, and Clover and Toast rates may differ by contract. How a flat percentage plus a per-transaction fee accumulates is walked through in taking card payments with Square.
The numbers also leave out what each plan includes. A lower rate on Clover comes with a higher software fee and a hardware purchase; Toast’s $69 plan includes the first terminal subscription, and Square’s plan prices exclude hardware entirely.

Hardware: who can bring their own
Toast is the most restrictive. Its pricing page states services “may only be used on approved Toast hardware,” and the Android-based devices are sold through Toast. NerdWallet lists a Toast Tap reader at $149 and a Go 3 handheld at $599, with starter kits from $1,113 to $1,454 that can be $0 upfront in exchange for a higher processing fee.
Square sells its own devices, and its Stand is sold without the iPad it holds. NerdWallet’s Square review, last updated February 18, 2026 per the page, lists a contactless-and-chip reader at $59, a Square Stand at $149 with the iPad not included, Square Terminal at $299, Square Handheld at $399, a two-screen Square Register at $799 to $899, and a register kit with cash drawer and printer from $1,189.
Clover’s own page prices the Mini at $849 and the Station Duo at $1,899 for purchase, with other devices listed by NerdWallet: Flex with printer at $749, Station Solo at $1,799, and a kitchen display system at $799 to $899 plus $25 a month.
Financing differs too. Toast’s payment options page describes Easy Pay, a 180-day lease repaid by withholding 0.75% of card sales once live, or 1.75% before going live. Clover’s pages show 36-month monthly payments as an alternative to buying, and Square’s pricing page, which lists hardware separately, carries no lease program in the text fetched. The cheapest financing on paper is not always the cheapest in total, since a lease repaid from sales and a 36-month payment plan both stretch the total over time.
The practical point for a kitchen is the printer and display. Square charges for kitchen display software by the device, Clover charges both hardware and a monthly fee, and Toast prices add-ons by quote. The guide on server-based and cloud POS covers the broader architecture question behind these hardware choices.
Contracts and the cost of leaving
Square’s pricing page says Plus and Premium offer a free 30-day trial and that a plan can be canceled or switched at any time. NerdWallet quotes “No contract” and lists the absence of termination fees among Square’s pros.
Clover’s POS software is month-to-month, per NerdWallet, but processing may carry a long-term contract, hardware promotions require three years, and a merchant that processes through Clover may owe an early termination fee for canceling within three years.
Toast’s Merchant Agreement renews automatically for one-year periods unless 30 days’ written notice is given, and defines an early termination fee: remaining software fees for subscriptions, or $150 times the months remaining for pay-as-you-go. NerdWallet reports terms of two to three years.

Support, offline operation and add-ons
Toast says its support, Toast Care, is included in every software subscription and available 24/7 by phone or web messaging. Square’s phone support runs 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. Pacific on weekdays for Plus, the same hours for the first 90 days on Free, and around the clock on Premium. NerdWallet lists Clover’s phone support as 24/7, with chat from 8 a.m. to 6 p.m. Eastern.
Offline behavior differs. Toast describes an offline mode that keeps taking orders, printing tickets and receipts, and accepting card payments during an outage. Square lists offline payments as included with every plan, with a catch: payments taken offline are declined if the device does not reconnect within 24 hours of the first offline payment, and the merchant bears the risk of declined or disputed payments. Clover’s pages fetched for this article did not describe an offline mode.
Payroll shows the same pattern. Square Payroll starts at $35 a month plus $6 per person paid, per Square’s page. Clover lists payroll integrations as an optional add-on, and Toast lists payroll among add-on categories priced by quote. Training and onboarding time should enter the decision too, which the post on training restaurant staff on a new POS treats in detail.

How the independent reviews frame the choice
NerdWallet calls Square a good fit for “small quick-service restaurants, cafes and bars,” and says its Plus plan is better for most food service businesses. For Toast, the reviewer rates it 4.4 out of 5, recommends it for multi-location and established full-service restaurants, and points cafes, breweries and quick-service spots to cheaper alternatives. For Clover, the verdict is a “solid option for brick-and-mortar businesses that need an individual merchant account,” with a note that Square plans cost less.
Each of those summaries is a reviewer’s judgment layered on top of the vendors’ own pages. The published numbers support a narrower reading: Square has the lowest exit cost, Clover’s quick-service processing rate is the lowest listed here but sits beside a higher software fee, and Toast ties its lowest processing price to hardware and contract terms that are harder to leave.
For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney, tax professional or financial advisor.
Sources
- https://squareup.com/us/en/point-of-sale/restaurants/pricing
- https://pos.toasttab.com/blog/on-the-line/toast-pricing
- https://pos.toasttab.com/pricing
- https://pos.toasttab.com/merchant-agreement
- https://www.clover.com/pricing/quick-service-restaurant
- https://www.nerdwallet.com/reviews/small-business/clover-pos-review
- https://www.nerdwallet.com/reviews/small-business/toast-pos-review
- https://www.nerdwallet.com/business/software/reviews/square-for-restaurants
All pages fetched at the time of writing.
