A point-of-sale system is a bundle of four decisions made at once: the software that rings up sales, the hardware that runs it, the company that processes card payments, and the contract that ties them together. Vendors tend to present the first as the product and the other three as details. The checklist below treats all four as equal, using pricing pages, contract text and New York State guidance read at the time of writing. Prices and terms change, and every figure should be confirmed against a written quote.
Start with what the counter actually does
The first screen of a checklist is the sales process itself. A counter that takes orders and payment in one motion needs different gear than a dining room where a server carries a handheld to the table. Vendors build tiers around that split. Clover’s full-service pricing page marks tableside ordering and firing as “Not Included” on its Starter tier and included on the two higher tiers, and lists tapping cards and mobile wallets as available only on certain devices within a tier. A tier that looks adequate on price can leave a device unable to take a contactless payment.
Questions for this stage:
- How many terminals, handhelds and kitchen screens are needed on the busiest day, not the average one?
- Does the plan include the customer-facing display, cash drawer and receipt printer, or are they priced separately?
- Which functions live in the base plan, and which are paid add-ons (loyalty, online ordering, payroll, gift cards)?
The cost of getting this wrong shows up at the register. Friction at payment is one of the places small shops lose sales, as covered in where small shops lose customers at checkout.
Hardware: owned, leased or locked
Hardware rules vary more than software prices. Toast states on its pricing page that its services “may only be used on approved Toast hardware,” and that Toast can change which devices are approved. Square sells hardware separately from its plans, with options starting at $59 per its restaurant pricing page. Clover’s pricing pages show devices either purchased outright or paid monthly over 36 months.
Financing deserves its own line on the checklist. Toast’s payment options page describes a 180-day lease called Easy Pay, repaid by withholding a share of card sales, with any remaining balance collected by ACH at term end. NerdWallet reports that Clover hardware promotions require a three-year contract, as set out in its Clover review. Those are two different obligations, and neither shows up in a monthly software price.
Checklist items: who owns the hardware at the end, what happens to it if the contract ends early, whether existing printers and tablets work, and how a failed device gets replaced.

Processing: bundled, separate or both
Most small-business systems bundle card processing, and the bundle usually decides the real cost. The same three questions apply to any vendor.
The first is the rate structure. Square’s restaurant page lists in-person rates that fall with the plan: 2.6% + 15¢ on Free, 2.5% + 15¢ on Plus, 2.4% + 15¢ on Premium. Clover’s quick-service page shows 2.3% + 10¢ in person and 3.5% + 10¢ for keyed-in cards. Toast leaves rates off its pricing page and describes itself as a payment facilitator working with processors. The walk-through in taking card payments with Square shows how a flat percentage plus a per-transaction fee adds up.
The second is whether a different processor can be used. NerdWallet notes that Clover’s POS can be paired with a third-party processor, while Toast’s service runs through its own payments arrangement. A system that forces its own processor also moves the leaving cost into the processing contract.
The third is how a lower rate is paid for. A cheaper rate on a higher-tier plan only helps above a certain monthly card volume. Using Square’s own published rates, the Free and Plus plans differ by 0.1 percentage point, so the $49 monthly Plus fee pays for itself only above about $49,000 in monthly card sales, assuming the same per-transaction cents. Volume breaks like that one belong in a spreadsheet before signing.
The fee list beyond the monthly price. Software price is one line. A complete checklist adds:
- Setup, installation and training charges. NerdWallet lists Toast on-site setup at $1,000 a day and remote installation at $800 a day.
- Per-device fees. Square’s page lists kitchen display software at $30 a month per device on Plus and $20 on Premium.
- Fees for faster deposits. Clover’s pages list Rapid Deposit at a 1.75% fee.
- Payroll and integrations. Square Payroll starts at $35 a month plus $6 per person paid. Clover marks payroll integrations as an optional add-on.
- Gift card, text-message and online-selling charges, which differ by plan.
The pattern is consistent across vendors. The advertised plan covers the register, and the extras sit in a pricing table further down the page or behind a quote.
Contract length, renewal and exit
Exit terms are the part of a POS decision hardest to see before signing and costliest to learn afterward. Square’s page says plans can be canceled or switched at any time. Clover’s POS software is month-to-month according to NerdWallet, while processing may require a long contract and cancellation within three years may trigger a fee if Clover is the processor.
Toast’s Merchant Agreement shows what a longer contract looks like in text: an initial term set by the order form, automatic renewal for one-year periods, a 30-day written notice requirement to stop the renewal, and an early termination fee. For subscriptions that fee is the remaining software fees, and for pay-as-you-go it is $150 multiplied by the months remaining. The agreement also waives the fee when the merchant terminates in response to a processing-rate or core-subscription price increase.
A reasonable checklist asks for four dates and numbers in writing: the end of the initial term, the last day to give non-renewal notice, the formula for early termination, and the notice period the vendor needs to change prices.

What happens when the system goes down
Outages are inevitable, so offline behavior belongs on the list. Toast describes an offline mode that continues to place orders, print tickets and receipts, and take card payments until the connection returns. Square lists offline payments as included with every plan, with a limit: they are declined if the device does not reconnect within 24 hours of the first offline payment, and the merchant is responsible for expired, declined or disputed payments taken offline.
Support hours matter as much as offline mode. Square’s page shows phone support from 6 a.m. to 6 p.m. Pacific on weekdays for Plus, the same window for the first 90 days on Free, and 24/7 on Premium. Toast says its support is included in every software subscription and open all day, every day. NerdWallet lists Clover’s phone support as 24/7. A restaurant open on weekends and late evenings should compare those hours with its own.
Questions to ask in writing: how long offline payments can be held, what the merchant risks on declined offline cards, and what the escalation path is at 9 p.m. on a Saturday.
Records, tax and data export in New York
A POS also becomes the record the state may ask to see. The New York Tax Department’s recordkeeping bulletin tells sales tax vendors to keep records for a minimum of three years. For cash registers and POS systems it lists the transaction detail that must be captured: individual items sold, selling price, tax due, invoice number, date, payment method, and POS terminal and transaction numbers. The audit trail or logging function must stay activated and operational at all times, including training-mode activity and changes to system setup. Summary reports and daily “Z” tapes alone are described as insufficient.
Two checklist items follow. A system should be able to export full transaction detail in a commonly used format, not only summaries, and the export should remain available after the account closes. The bulletin says that if a POS cannot store data for the whole retention period, the removed data must be kept in a “machine-sensible and auditable form.” For the broader picture, see what records a small business keeps and for how long.

Security questions for the vendor
The PCI Security Standards Council publishes a short list of questions to ask vendors. Among them: whether the agreement includes clauses requiring the vendor to maintain PCI DSS compliance, whether the product stores payment card information locally, whether it protects card data with strong encryption, whether remote access is required for support and whether it is always active, and whether the vendor carries insurance covering data breaches tied to its product.
The Council’s small merchant guide adds practical points: choose a device from the list of PCI-approved PTS devices that supports EMV chip, ask whether terminal encryption is done through a point-to-point encryption solution, change default passwords, and give each employee a unique login.
For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney, tax professional or financial advisor.
Sources
- https://www.clover.com/pricing/restaurant
- https://www.clover.com/pricing/quick-service-restaurant
- https://pos.toasttab.com/pricing
- https://pos.toasttab.com/pricing-payment-options
- https://pos.toasttab.com/merchant-agreement
- https://squareup.com/us/en/point-of-sale/restaurants/pricing
- https://www.nerdwallet.com/reviews/small-business/clover-pos-review
- https://www.nerdwallet.com/reviews/small-business/toast-pos-review
- https://www.tax.ny.gov/pubs_and_bulls/tg_bulletins/st/record-keeping_requirements_for_sales_tax_vendors.htm
- https://listings.pcisecuritystandards.org/pdfs/Small_Merchant_Questions_To_Ask_Your_Vendors.pdf
- https://www.pcisecuritystandards.org/wp-content/uploads/2022/05/Small_Merchant_Guide_to_Safe_Payments.pdf
All pages fetched at the time of writing.
