Independent Contractor or Employee: The IRS Test, Form SS-8 and What New York Adds

Doorway between a freelancer's laptop workspace and a shop counter with an apron on a hook.

A written agreement that calls a worker an independent contractor settles very little. The IRS puts the question in terms of the relationship that actually exists, and a business that guesses wrong inherits payroll taxes it never withheld. The IRS groups its evidence into three categories: behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship, and New York layers its own agencies’ tests on top.

How the IRS frames the question

Publication 15 states the common-law rule in plain terms: what matters is that the business has “the right to control the details of how the services are performed.” The same publication adds that if an employer-employee relationship exists, it does not matter what the arrangement is called.

No set number of factors

The IRS declines to give a checklist score. Its page on the subject says there is no “magic” or set number of factors that makes a worker an employee or an independent contractor. A factor that carries weight in one arrangement may carry none in another, and the agency advises businesses to document each factor considered.

Who bears the burden of deciding

Classification falls to the payer. The Department of Labor puts it directly: “Employers are responsible for determining whether a worker is an employee” under the Fair Labor Standards Act, which is why the three categories below look at behavior and money instead of paperwork.

Behavioral control

The first category asks whether the business has the right to direct what the worker does and how the job gets done. The IRS says an employee is generally subject to the business’s instructions about when, where and how to work. Its examples of such instructions include when and where the work happens, which tools or equipment to use, whom to hire or assign to help, where to buy supplies and services, and what order or sequence to follow.

Training

Training sits close to the center of this category. If a business trains a worker in how to do the job, the IRS calls that “strong evidence that the worker is an employee.” Periodic or ongoing training on procedures and methods counts for even more. Independent contractors, by contrast, ordinarily use their own methods.

A restaurant that hands a part-time cook a station sheet, a schedule and a required prep order is describing behavioral control, whatever the tax form at year-end says.

Craftsperson's hands working with their own tools at a studio workbench in window light.

Financial control and the type of relationship

Financial control

The second category looks at the business side of the job. The IRS’s financial control page lists four factors:

  • Significant investment. A contractor often has a significant investment in equipment, though a large outlay is not required, since some work needs little gear.
  • Unreimbursed expenses. Contractors are more likely than employees to carry costs no one repays, especially fixed ongoing ones.
  • Services available to the market. A contractor is generally free to seek out business opportunities, usually by advertising, keeping a visible business location or staying available in the market.
  • Method of payment. Employees typically receive a guaranteed regular wage; a contractor is usually paid a flat fee for the job.

Hourly pay for contractors is common in some fields, law among them, so no single factor decides the matter.

Type of relationship

The third category covers the arrangement around the work. On written contracts, the IRS says a contract alone is “not sufficient to determine the worker’s status.” Benefits such as insurance, pensions and paid leave are typical of employment, but the lack of them does not by itself make someone a contractor.

Permanence matters as well. Hiring with the expectation that the relationship will continue indefinitely, rather than for a specific project or period, is generally evidence of an intent to create an employer-employee relationship. So does work that sits at the center of the business: when a worker performs a key activity, the business is more likely to have the right to direct and control it. The IRS’s own example is a law firm that hires an attorney.

Asking the IRS: Form SS-8

When the facts do not point one way, a business or a worker can ask the IRS to decide. Form SS-8 is titled Determination of Worker Status for Purposes of Federal Employment Taxes and Income Tax Withholding, and the IRS page says firms and workers file it to request a determination of a worker’s status. Either side may file. The IRS’s worker classification page says a determination may take at least six months.

The reclassification program

A business that already treats workers as contractors and decides to change course has a separate route. Under the Voluntary Classification Settlement Program, the business applies on Form 8952 at least 120 days before it wants to begin treating the workers as employees.

Eligibility has conditions. The business must have consistently treated the workers as contractors and filed all required Forms 1099 for the previous three years, and it cannot be under an IRS employment tax audit or under a Department of Labor or state agency audit over the classification. The payment is 10 percent of the employment tax that would have been due on the workers’ pay for the most recent tax year, figured under the reduced rates of section 3509(a), with no interest or penalties on that amount.

Overhead view of a desk with a calculator, ledger notebook, pen and a blank form beside a cup of tea.

What misclassification costs

The IRS’s own publications state the liability in terms of the taxes that should have been withheld. If an employer does not withhold because it treated an employee as a nonemployee, it is generally liable for the unpaid Social Security and Medicare taxes and the withheld income tax, and it continues to owe the full employer share of Social Security and Medicare. Reduced section 3509 rates may lower the bill, but they are not available when the employer intentionally disregarded the withholding requirement.

Relief provisions

Relief exists, with conditions. Publication 15-A says an employer may be relieved from paying employment taxes for a worker if it filed the required federal information returns consistently with how it treated the worker, and if neither it nor a predecessor treated any worker in a substantially similar position as an employee for any period beginning after 1977. Where there is no reasonable basis for the treatment, the same publication says the employer is liable and the relief provision will not apply.

Wage and hour rules

Tax is only one layer. The US Department of Labor says misclassified employees may not receive the minimum wage and overtime pay to which they are entitled under the Fair Labor Standards Act. For that law, the agency’s fact sheet lists six economic reality factors: opportunity for profit or loss, investments by the worker and the employer, permanence, nature and degree of control, whether the work is integral to the employer’s business, and skill and initiative.

The fact sheet also says the 2024 rule behind that analysis is the subject of litigation, points to Field Assistance Bulletin 2025-1 for the Wage and Hour Division’s current enforcement position, and notes a proposed rule announced February 26, 2026, with comments due April 28, 2026. A business relying on the federal wage test should check the Department’s page for its current status.

Handshake across a small business counter with a card reader and display case blurred behind.

New York’s own tests

New York agencies reach the same question for different programs, and their pages are blunt. The State Department of Labor defines the problem this way: “Misclassification occurs if an employer treats people as independent contractors when they are employees.” It lists the obligations misclassification is used to avoid: unemployment insurance, workers’ compensation, Social Security, tax withholding, temporary disability, and minimum wage and overtime. A Joint Enforcement Task Force that includes the Department of Labor, the Attorney General’s office, the Department of Taxation and Finance and the Workers’ Compensation Board takes reports of it.

The Department of Labor’s factors

A separate Department of Labor page says that purposeful misclassification is fraudulent. Indicators of an employer-employee relationship on that page include an employer who dictates when, where and how work is done and supervises it directly, sets hours and pay rates, requires permission for absences, supplies the facilities and tools, or pays a salary or hourly rate. Independent contractors, the page says, are in business for themselves and make their services available to the public.

The Workers’ Compensation Board’s factors

The Board’s guidance on identifying an independent contractor sorts workers into three tracks. In construction, a worker injured on or after October 26, 2010 is presumed to be the contractor’s employee unless the hiring business proves all three parts of a statutory test: freedom from control, work outside the business’s usual course, and an independently established trade. The worker’s own entity must then meet twelve criteria. A comparable presumption covers licensed drivers moving goods in commercial motor vehicles, with eleven criteria for the driver’s business entity.

For every other industry, the Board lists indicators of independence: working free from direction and subject only to the desired result, holding a federal EIN or filing business tax returns, keeping a separate business location, bearing the risk of profit or loss, carrying liability insurance, advertising, and supplying equipment and permits.

One sentence on that page carries weight for small employers: “A business cannot require employees working for that business to obtain their own workers’ compensation insurance policy.” Where a general contractor uses subcontractors, the Board adds, insurers often charge premiums for them unless they show their own coverage.

The New York pages reviewed do not publish a penalty schedule for misclassification, so no dollar figures are given here for the state. An owner weighing a specific arrangement can start with what the first accountant meeting should cover, and an owner who decides the worker is an employee can follow the steps in hiring a first employee in New York.

For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney, tax professional or financial advisor.

Sources