Chargebacks: What They Cost and How a Small Business Responds

Desk with a laptop showing a blurred form, clipped paper receipts and a mug.

A chargeback takes the money back before the argument starts. When a cardholder disputes a payment, the funds are pulled from the business first, held for the length of the dispute, and returned only if the cardholder’s bank decides the case in the business’s favor. The process runs on short deadlines and on documents, and the processors that handle it describe the rules in some detail. The Square and Stripe figures below come from their own help and pricing pages as read at the time of writing, and the consumer-side rules come from the Federal Trade Commission. This is general information, and the terms in a particular processing agreement govern.

The Disputes Process, Square on YouTube

How a dispute moves from complaint to decision

The money moves first

Stripe’s documentation on how disputes work says the card network pulls the disputed funds from the Stripe balance and holds them for the entire duration of the dispute, and that Stripe debits the disputed amount plus a dispute fee. Square’s dispute article describes the same sequence: Square places an immediate hold on the disputed funds by withholding them from the Square balance or debiting the linked bank account. If neither can cover the hold, the balance goes negative and future payments go toward the shortfall.

Reasons a cardholder gives

Square lists three: fraudulent activity, goods or services not received, and goods or services not as described. The reason matters because it decides which evidence helps.

The clock

Stripe says card networks typically let cardholders start a dispute within 120 days of the original payment, with more time allowed in some situations, and that the window for pre-paid events or travel can start on the event date. After a chargeback is created, the business usually has 7 to 21 days to respond, depending on the network. The issuer then has roughly 60 to 75 days to decide, and the full lifecycle can take two to three months. Square gives seven days from the first notification email to submit information and says the bank can take up to 90 days from the start of the dispute to decide.

Inquiries before chargebacks

Some networks use a preliminary stage. Stripe describes an inquiry as a request for information from the card issuer, often because the cardholder does not recognize the transaction description. American Express and Discover use it most, and Stripe says Mastercard and Visa no longer do. A satisfactory answer or a full refund resolves an inquiry without a dispute fee, while silence can look like acceptance and push it into a chargeback the page calls likely unwinnable.

What a chargeback costs

Fees

Stripe’s pricing page lists a $15.00 dispute received fee, a $15.00 dispute countered fee for each dispute answered manually, and a $15.00 appeal fee. The countered fee is refunded when the dispute is won and not when it is lost, and the appeal fee is not refunded even on a win. Stripe’s support page on its 2025 dispute pricing shows the countered fee beginning with disputes initiated after June 17, 2025. The documentation adds that Stripe never returns the received fee unless a contract says so.

Square’s article states there is no fee for dispute management services for chargebacks and that Square covers the fee for every dispute it works with the seller to challenge. What Square does not return is the processing fee on a lost payment.

An example in numbers

The arithmetic below uses an $80 sale and takes the published terms at face value. The Square processing fee uses the 2.5% + 15¢ in-person rate shown on Square’s pricing page for Square Plus. The product or service already delivered is not counted.

Outcome Stripe Square
Dispute won $15 received fee kept by Stripe; $80 returned; $15 countered fee refunded $80 returned, processing fee ($2.15) released
Dispute lost, evidence submitted $80 lost + $15 received + $15 countered = $110 $80 lost + $2.15 processing fee not refunded = $82.15
Refunded before any dispute is filed $80 refunded; no dispute fee $80 refunded

The costs outside the table

The merchandise or meal is gone in a fraud case. Time spent assembling documents comes out of an owner’s week. On Stripe, a business’s dispute rate with the card network goes up with every dispute, a measure the documentation says increases when a dispute is received. The effect of a high rate on a processing relationship is something to ask a processor about directly, because the pages fetched do not give thresholds.

Paper receipt and plain payment card on a counter beside a card terminal.

Responding: deadlines and evidence

Accept or challenge

Square’s form asks one question: whether to return the funds or challenge. Answering “No” refunds the customer, and answering “Yes” opens an upload step for supporting documents. Square’s page tells the seller to collect whatever documentation the form asks for, and says the reason code and disputed amount identify which transaction is at issue. Stripe’s documentation states that once a dispute is active, the only way to overturn it is by submitting evidence; even when a customer says the dispute was withdrawn, the business must still respond for the dispute to close in its favor.

Refunds during an open dispute

Stripe notes that a business cannot issue a refund outside the dispute process while the dispute is open. A refund to the customer, made directly, risks paying twice. On Square, the article warns that a refund sent to the card-issuing bank can take an additional two to seven business days to post.

What the documents have to match

The evidence has to answer the reason given. A not-received claim calls for proof of delivery or pickup, a not-as-described claim calls for the order terms and any communication, and a fraud claim turns on how the card was presented. Keeping the underlying records is therefore part of the response. The post on what records a small business keeps and for how long covers the retention side, and the return policy the customer saw at purchase is the subject of a returns and refund policy for a small online shop.

Disputes that cannot be won

ACH payments

Square’s article says Square cannot challenge ACH disputes under NACHA rules. The returned funds are removed from the account, and the business must settle the matter with the customer directly.

Swiped chip cards

Square states that a seller generally covers the loss when a customer disputes a payment made by swiping a chip card. Inserting the chip rather than swiping it is a habit that staff learn at the counter, and the post on training restaurant staff on a new POS system covers that side of the rollout.

Network and local rules

Stripe lists some disputes as unchallengeable under card-network rules or local regulations, and says it closes those as lost on notification. Discover inquiries left without evidence can turn into one of these. After the issuer decides, the outcome is final for all parties, though Stripe notes a customer can still withdraw a dispute even after a loss and that late wins occasionally occur.

Shipping box with a blank label on a doorstep in morning light.

Reducing the number of disputes

Recognizable descriptions

Because Stripe ties many inquiries to cardholders not recognizing a transaction description, the name that appears on the statement deserves attention. A statement that carries the trade name customers know avoids the dispute that starts with a cardholder who does not recognize the charge.

Early fraud warnings

Stripe’s documentation says early fraud warnings come from reports that card issuers on the Visa, Mastercard and JCB networks generate to flag suspicious payments, and that about 40% of Visa and Mastercard warnings become fraud disputes if the charge is not refunded, with the rate varying by network and amount. The page’s own analysis is that refunding makes the most sense on charges roughly at or below the dispute fee, and that refunding all warnings regardless of likelihood is not a good strategy. The strategy applies to Stripe merchants specifically, but the arithmetic is general: a $12 charge costs less to refund than to dispute, while an $800 charge may be worth contesting.

Quick, ordinary service

Stripe states that proactive customer service and transaction clarification can avoid a dispute entirely. A customer who can reach the business and get a refund in a day has less reason to call the bank.

Open binder with colored tabs of order paperwork beside a pen.

The cardholder’s side of the clock

Billing-error rights

The FTC’s consumer page on disputing credit card charges explains the rules that sit behind many of these cases. A cardholder’s written letter has to reach the issuer within 60 days after the first bill with the error was sent. Qualifying errors include unauthorized charges, a wrong date or amount, and items not accepted or not delivered as agreed. The issuer must acknowledge the complaint in writing within 30 days and resolve the dispute within 90 days. While the investigation runs, the cardholder can withhold payment on the disputed amount.

Two clocks

The cardholder’s 60-day letter window and the networks’ typical 120-day dispute window are separate numbers from separate sources, and a business cannot assume either one has closed. A refund the business already intends to give is cheaper the day it is issued than after a dispute opens.

For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney, tax professional or financial advisor.

Sources

All pages fetched at the time of writing.