A stylist who rents a chair and a stylist who works on payroll can stand side by side in the same salon, cut the same hair for the same clients and look identical to the public. To the Internal Revenue Service, the New York Department of Labor and the New York Department of State, the two are entirely different arrangements, and the paperwork that follows each one has little in common. The label on the agreement does not settle which arrangement exists.
Video: Women’s Business Development Center (WBDC)
How the IRS draws the line
Three groups of evidence. The IRS sorts the facts of a working relationship into behavioral control, financial control and the type of relationship. Behavioral control asks whether the business directs what the worker does and how the work is done. Financial control looks at how the worker is paid, whether expenses are reimbursed and who supplies tools. The relationship category weighs written contracts, employee-type benefits, whether the arrangement is ongoing and whether the work is a key part of the business.
No scorecard. The agency states that no set number of factors makes a worker one thing or the other, and that no single factor decides the matter. It also says a factor that carries weight in one case may carry none in another. The IRS tells businesses to consider the whole relationship and to document each factor relied on (IRS).
Right to control is enough. A separate IRS page on common-law employees makes the labels irrelevant: the actual relationship determines status, and both full-time and part-time workers can be employees (IRS). The employer does not have to exercise control at every moment. Holding the right to control is what counts.
What the IRS says about booth renters
Publication 4902, Tax Tips for the Cosmetology & Barber Industry, is the IRS’s tax guide for the field. The copy fetched for this article is dated 2-2011, so it predates several form changes, but its description of the booth renter relationship is the most direct IRS language on the subject (IRS Publication 4902).
Questions for the owner. The publication asks who sets shop hours and shifts, who sets prices, who buys supplies, who sets appointments and who pays for expenses such as insurance and advertising.
Signs of a renter. A booth renter leases space and operates as an independent contractor. The listed indicators are a key to the establishment, self-set hours, self-purchased products, a separate phone number and business name, and self-set prices. Where those are missing, the publication says the renter is likely an employee.
What a renter handles alone. A renter keeps personal records, files and pays personal taxes, reports income including tips on Schedule C, pays self-employment tax and makes quarterly estimated payments because nothing is withheld. The publication also tells renters to issue Form 1099-MISC for business rent above $600 paid to non-corporate landlords. The IRS’s current Form 1099-MISC page lists rents among payments of at least $600, though thresholds change by payment year and a tax professional should confirm the figure that applies.

What the employee model requires of an owner
An owner with stylists on payroll takes on the withholding and reporting work itself. Per the 2011 publication, that means withholding federal income tax and Social Security and Medicare tax from wages, paying the employer’s share of Social Security and Medicare, possibly paying federal unemployment tax, issuing Form W-2 by January 31 and filing Form 941 quarterly and Form 940 annually (IRS Publication 4902).
The IRS’s employment tax overview adds that federal unemployment tax is paid only by the employer and is not withheld from employees’ pay, and that employers withhold an Additional Medicare Tax of 0.9% on wages above $200,000 in a calendar year with no employer match (IRS).
Tips change the calculation. Employees must report tips to the employer by the 10th of the month after receiving them, and the employer collects income tax and the employee’s Social Security and Medicare tax on them. Renters report tips as part of their own gross receipts (IRS Publication 4902).
Workers’ compensation. The New York Workers’ Compensation Board says “Virtually all employers in New York State must provide workers’ compensation coverage”, and that for-profit businesses generally must cover anyone working under their direction and control. A business also cannot require its employees to buy their own policy or contribute to one (NYS Workers’ Compensation Board). The same page allows a business to require a subcontractor that has its own employees to carry coverage.
For the state-side steps of a first hire, hiring a first employee in New York covers what the state requires.
How New York tests the same question
The Department of Labor. The unemployment insurance side applies common-law tests developed in court decisions, since the statute does not define “independent contractor.” The central question is whether the party paying has, or has the right to have, supervision, direction and control over the work. Independence shows up as freedom from that control, an independent business, services offered to the public, risk of profit or loss and the choice of one’s own hours. Set hours, required meetings, provided tools, a set pay rate and the right to end services on short notice point toward employment (NYS Department of Labor).
A written agreement does not bind the department. Its examiners look at the actual relationship, and an employer that skipped contributions on the assumption that a worker was a contractor may face additional assessments and interest if the worker is later found to be an employee.
The Workers’ Compensation Board. Outside construction and transportation, the Board lists conditions that point toward contractor status. They include freedom from direction or control, a separate business location, a worker’s own federal employer identification number or business tax filings for the prior year, services to other businesses, a chance to profit or lose, the worker’s own liability insurance and advertising of the worker’s own business. The Board adds that it has often found people alleged to be subcontractors to be employees once they filed claims (NYS Workers’ Compensation Board).
One factor on that list, a worker’s own employer identification number, connects to a setup step explained in do you need an EIN.

The Department of State licenses behind each model
New York adds a layer that the federal and labor tests do not: licensing of the salon and of the individuals in it.
The renter has a defined legal status. Under the Department of State’s rules, an area renter is a licensed individual “not on the payroll of or subject to the withholding of taxes by a licensed business”. The department’s FAQ describes an area renter as a licensed operator working in a salon but not employed by its owner, an independent contractor who needs an Area Renter license in addition to an operator license (NYS Department of State FAQ). The Area Renter license alone does not permit customer services.
Three licenses can be in play. The department states that each person who provides services must hold a license in the discipline, such as cosmetology, esthetics, nail specialty, natural hair styling or waxing. A business license is required to own, control or operate an appearance enhancement business, a requirement that reaches sole proprietors, partners, shareholders, officers and area renters. Barbering at a location carries a separate Barber Shop license under Article 28 (NYS Department of State FAQ).
The owner takes part in the renter’s application. When a renter applies online, the shop owner is notified and has to complete a Shop Owner Affirmation. If the shop closes, the renter’s license is cancelled. A name change cancels the renter’s license under the old name, and a change of ownership requires every associated renter to reapply (NYS Department of State FAQ).
Fees and security. The department’s business page lists a $60 initial application fee and a $60 renewal fee for the Appearance Enhancement Business and Area Renter licenses. Applicants must be 18 or older and show a surety bond or insurance of at least $25,000 per occurrence and $75,000 in the aggregate. A wage bond applies to businesses with full-time nail service workers, starting at $25,000 for two to five workers (NYS Department of State). The statute sets a four-year license term (NYS Department of State, Appearance Enhancement Law).
Penalties for skipping a license. Operating a business without a license is a misdemeanor punishable by up to six months in jail or a fine of up to $2,500, or both. Practicing without a license brings civil penalties of up to $500, $1,000 and $2,500 for a first, second and later violation, and operating without the required bond or liability coverage carries a civil penalty of up to $2,500 (NYS Department of State, Appearance Enhancement Law).

What misclassification costs and how to get an answer
Federal exposure. An owner who treats an employee as a contractor without a reasonable basis may be liable for that worker’s employment taxes (IRS). Relief under Section 530 is available only to a business that has a reasonable basis, files all required information returns consistently with its treatment of the worker and has not treated any worker in a substantially similar position as an employee after 1977. The relief does not turn the worker into a contractor.
Asking the agencies. Either the business or the worker may file Form SS-8 to request an IRS determination, and the IRS warns that a determination can take at least six months. A Voluntary Classification Settlement Program, applied for on Form 8952, lets a business reclassify workers as employees going forward with partial relief from federal employment taxes. In New York, employers can write to the Department of Labor’s Liability and Determination Section for a status determination on the unemployment insurance side (NYS Department of Labor).
How the models compare in practice. Booth rental places record-keeping, tax payments and the renter’s own expenses on the renter, while the owner’s role narrows to that of a landlord with a lease and a Shop Owner Affirmation to complete. The IRS indicators of a renter, from self-set prices to a separate business name, describe independence that the owner has to leave intact. Employment keeps control with the owner and brings payroll taxes, workers’ compensation coverage and unemployment contributions along with it. A salon that mixes the two has to keep each stylist’s actual arrangement consistent with the model chosen, because the agencies look at conduct and not at the lease.
For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney, tax professional or financial advisor.
Sources
- IRS, Independent Contractor (Self-Employed) or Employee?: https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/independent-contractor-self-employed-or-employee
- IRS, Employee (Common-Law Employee): https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/employee-common-law-employee
- IRS, Understanding Employment Taxes: https://www.irs.gov/businesses/small-businesses-self-employed/understanding-employment-taxes
- IRS, Publication 4902, Tax Tips for the Cosmetology & Barber Industry (2-2011): https://www.irs.gov/pub/irs-pdf/p4902.pdf
- IRS, About Form 1099-MISC: https://www.irs.gov/forms-pubs/about-form-1099-misc
- NYS Department of Labor, Independent Contractors (IA 318.14): https://dol.ny.gov/independent-contractors-ia-31814
- NYS Workers’ Compensation Board, coverage required: https://www.wcb.ny.gov/content/main/coverage-requirements-wc/wc-coverage-required.jsp
- NYS Workers’ Compensation Board, identifying an independent contractor: https://www.wcb.ny.gov/content/main/Employers/identifying-independent-contractor.jsp
- NYS Department of State, Become an Appearance Enhancement Business: https://dos.ny.gov/become-appearance-enhancement-business
- NYS Department of State, Appearance Enhancement Business FAQ: https://dos.ny.gov/frequently-asked-questions-appearance-enhancement-business
- NYS Department of State, Appearance Enhancement Law: https://dos.ny.gov/appearance-enhancement-law
- Video: Women’s Business Development Center, “Session 5: Federal Taxes When Hiring Employees or Independent Contractors”: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=A2Pys7MKrYo
- Till Post, hiring a first employee in New York: https://tillpost.com/hiring-first-employee-new-york/
- Till Post, do you need an EIN: https://tillpost.com/do-you-need-an-ein-what-the-irs-says/
