A POS system calculates sales tax only as accurately as the rates and item settings loaded into it, and in New York the rate depends on where the sale is delivered, not where the register sits. Both Square and Toast say as much in their own help pages: Square states that it is “solely your responsibility to accurately configure, charge, collect, and remit applicable taxes”, and Toast notes in its tax setup article that it does not determine whether taxes apply to a given business. The New York State Department of Taxation and Finance publishes the rules the settings have to match. This is general information drawn from those pages as they stood at the time of writing, not advice for a particular business.
Registration comes before the first taxable sale
The Certificate of Authority
The Department’s registration page says every person who sells taxable tangible personal property or taxable services must register before beginning business, including a seller who works from home, appears as a temporary vendor, or sells only once a year. A POS that charges tax without a registration behind it collects money the business has no standing to hold. The steps for the state side of that process are covered in an earlier post on registering a business in New York.
Trustee status
Publication 750, the Department’s guide to sales tax, puts the consequence plainly: a registered vendor becomes a trustee for the state. Tax collected at the register is not revenue. Publication 750 adds that certain responsible persons can be held personally liable for unpaid tax. The Department also encourages all vendors to open a separate bank account for sales tax voluntarily, and it can require one from vendors who failed to remit or filed late.
Loading the right rate
State plus local
The state rate is 4 percent, according to the Department’s rates page, and the combined rate adds whatever the city, county or school district imposes. The same page describes New York sales tax as a destination tax: the delivery location, or the point where the seller hands over possession, fixes the rate. Taxable sales within the Metropolitan Commuter Transportation District carry an additional 0.375 percent, which is already folded into the county figures below.
Long Island figures
Publication 718, the Department’s rate schedule, lists 8¾ percent for Suffolk County (reporting code 4711) and 8⅝ percent for Nassau County (reporting code 2811), effective March 1, 2025, with a footnote that the MCTD portion is included. The rates page notes that combined rates vary by county and by city, so a county figure is a starting point, and the Department’s rate publications bulletin points to a “Find sales tax rates” tool that looks up a rate from a customer’s address and ZIP code. A shop that ships, delivers or caters outside its home county needs that lookup, because the in-store rate would be wrong for those orders.
Where the setting lives
Square creates a tax under Settings in the Dashboard, where a name, a rate and the locations are entered, and the tax can be additive (a separate receipt line) or inclusive (folded into the price). Toast offers three rate types: percent, fixed, and tax table, plus a default rate that new menus and items inherit unless a menu group or item overrides it. Toast’s default rounding is half-even. The pages fetched for this article give no New York rounding rule, so a bookkeeper or the Department should confirm how a POS’s rounding behavior fits the return.
Square also offers automatically generated tax rates for delivery, pickup and shipping. Its help page says tax enrollment through the product “does not constitute registration with any tax authority”, so the registration step above still has to happen separately.

Deciding what is taxable
Prepared food and drink
The Department’s list of taxable items includes food and beverages sold by restaurants, taverns and caterers, while most food for home consumption and most services are exempt. Tax Bulletin ST-806 fills in the restaurant detail. Food and drink for on-premises consumption is taxable whether hot or cold. Heated food is taxable even when sold to go, and takeout sandwiches are taxable even when unheated. Cold, unheated takeout food other than sandwiches, and takeout drinks, are taxable only if sold in a form different from how a grocery store would sell them. The bulletin’s example of a nontaxable item is a dozen bagels sold to go in a bag.
Why dining-option settings can mislead
Both Square and Toast can tie tax to how an order is placed. Toast’s dining option setting includes a choice titled “No Tax for Takeout and Delivery,” and it separately offers a takeout rate that, per its help page, “only applies to orders with the Takeout dining option” and leaves delivery at the standard rate. Because ST-806 treats heated takeout food and takeout sandwiches as taxable, a blanket takeout exemption in New York would undercharge on exactly those items. The tax class belongs on the item, with the exception cases (the bagels, a quart of milk) marked individually.
Bundles and combinations
One price covering a taxable and a nontaxable item makes the whole price taxable under ST-806, which uses a kids’ meal that includes a carton of milk as its example. Publication 750 adds a retail requirement: a seller who skips written receipts under the alternate unit price method must label, display or list taxable and nontaxable products separately so the two can be told apart. Gift cards fall under a different rule, since the sale of a set-dollar gift certificate is not taxable, and tax applies when the certificate is later used for a taxable purchase.
Retail items
A shop selling goods needs the same item-level discipline. Publication 750 notes that clothing and footwear under $110 per item (or per pair of shoes) are generally exempt from the state tax, while the local exemption applies only where the county or city has elected it. A POS that applies one flat rate to every product misses that distinction.
Delivery fees, service charges and tips
Delivery and shipping
Tax Bulletin ST-838 says shipping or delivery charges that the seller includes on its bill are taxable when the product is taxable, and nontaxable when the product is. If taxable and nontaxable items share a single charge, the entire bill is taxable, delivery included. ST-806 applies the same logic to restaurants: a fee charged to deliver taxable food or drink is part of the taxable total. In Square, delivery fees can be taxed or exempted by a setting on the tax, and the setting should follow the item’s status rather than a habit.
Mandatory gratuities
A voluntary tip left by a customer is not subject to sales tax. An automatically added gratuity is a different matter. Tax Bulletin ST-320 says it escapes tax only when three conditions hold: the charge appears separately on the bill, it is labeled as a gratuity, and the business gives the entire amount to its employees. If any condition fails, the gratuity is taxable along with the rest of the bill. Service charges not specifically listed as gratuities are taxable. For a POS, that means a large-party charge needs to be built as a gratuity, labeled that way on the receipt, and routed fully to staff, or it should be set up as a taxable service charge.

What the receipt and the records must show
The receipt
When a receipt is given, Publication 750 requires the sales tax amount to be stated separately. Stores that do not give a written receipt can use an alternate unit price method, but they must post a sign saying the price includes sales tax.
Transaction-level records
Tax Bulletin ST-770 is the one most worth reading before choosing POS settings. It says daily summary or “Z” tapes alone are not sufficient, and that a register tape must list each item sold in enough detail to tell whether tax applied. For electronic systems it names the details a record should hold: individual items sold, selling price, tax due, invoice number, date, method of payment, and the POS terminal and transaction numbers. It also calls for sequential transaction numbers, records of all POS terminal activity, procedures to account for voids and cancellations, and an audit trail that stays active even in training mode and during setup changes.
Retention is a minimum of three years from the return’s due date or filing date, whichever is later, and data must stay in a commonly used, machine-readable format. The bulletin adds that when a POS lacks storage for three years, the removed data has to be transferred and kept, and the same applies when changing systems. A migration plan therefore needs an export of transaction history. General guidance on keeping paperwork is in an earlier post on what records a small business keeps and for how long.

Filing and paying what the POS collects
Frequency
Tax Bulletin ST-275 sets the schedule. A vendor with less than $300,000 in taxable receipts, taxable purchases, rents and amusement charges in the previous quarter files quarterly on Form ST-100, with returns due 20 days after the quarter ends. Reaching $300,000 or more in a quarter moves a vendor to monthly (part-quarterly) filing, due 20 days after each month ends. Some wholesalers and manufacturers file annually, with a March 20 due date.
Returns with no sales
The Department’s filing page states that a return is due even if the business made no taxable sales or purchases during the period. A seasonal shop that closes for winter still files.
The collection credit
Publication 750 describes a vendor collection credit equal to 5 percent of taxes and fees collected, up to $200 per quarter or longer period, available to vendors who file and pay on time. Before each return is filed, the POS’s tax report for the period can be compared with the register totals, and any gap traced to an item setting. An accountant can review the item list at the same time, a point covered in the post on questions for a first accountant meeting.
For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney, tax professional or financial advisor.
Sources
- NYS Department of Taxation and Finance, Register as a sales tax vendor: https://www.tax.ny.gov/bus/st/register.htm
- NYS Department of Taxation and Finance, Sales tax rates: https://www.tax.ny.gov/bus/st/rates.htm
- NYS Publication 718, Sales and Use Tax Rates by Jurisdiction: https://www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/publications/sales/pub718.pdf
- NYS Tax Bulletin ST-820, Sales Tax Rate Publications: https://www.tax.ny.gov/pubs_and_bulls/tg_bulletins/st/sales_tax_rate_publications.htm
- NYS Department of Taxation and Finance, Products, services and transactions subject to sales tax: https://www.tax.ny.gov/bus/st/subject.htm
- NYS Tax Bulletin ST-806, Sales by Restaurants, Taverns, and Similar Establishments: https://tax.ny.gov/pubs_and_bulls/tg_bulletins/st/sales_by_restaurants.htm
- NYS Tax Bulletin ST-320, Gratuities and Service Charges: https://www.tax.ny.gov/pubs_and_bulls/tg_bulletins/st/gratuities.htm
- NYS Tax Bulletin ST-838, Shipping and Delivery Charges: https://www.tax.ny.gov/pubs_and_bulls/tg_bulletins/st/shipping_and_delivery_charges.htm
- NYS Tax Bulletin ST-770, Record-Keeping Requirements for Sales Tax Vendors: https://www.tax.ny.gov/pubs_and_bulls/tg_bulletins/st/record-keeping_requirements_for_sales_tax_vendors.htm
- NYS Tax Bulletin ST-275, Filing Requirements for Sales and Use Tax Returns: https://www.tax.ny.gov/pubs_and_bulls/tg_bulletins/st/filing_requirements_for_sales_and_use_tax_returns.htm
- NYS Department of Taxation and Finance, File sales tax returns: https://www.tax.ny.gov/bus/st/filing_sales_tax_returns.htm
- NYS Department of Taxation and Finance, Segregated sales tax bank account: https://www.tax.ny.gov/bus/st/bank.htm
- NYS Publication 750, A Guide to Sales Tax in New York State (11/15): https://www.tax.ny.gov/pdf/publications/sales/pub750.pdf
- Square Support, Create and manage your tax settings: https://squareup.com/help/us/en/article/5061-create-and-manage-your-tax-settings
- Toast Support, Set Up Tax Rates and Adjust Tax Options: https://support.toasttab.com/en/article/Setting-Up-Tax-Rates-and-Adjusting-Tax-Options
- Toast Support, Set Up a Takeout Tax Rate: https://support.toasttab.com/en/article/Setting-Up-a-Takeout-Tax-Rate
- NYSTaxDept, NYS Sales Tax Starting a Business: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=gZZUIT8IUG4
All pages fetched at the time of writing.
