How Card Processing Fees Work: Flat Rate, Interchange-Plus and Subscription Pricing

A customer's hand holding a contactless card over a card reader on a shop counter.

Every card sale carries a cost made of three layers, and the three common pricing models differ mainly in how much of that cost is shown. According to Stripe’s explainer on interchange-plus pricing, the layers are interchange, paid to the bank that issued the customer’s card; a network assessment, paid to a network such as Visa or Mastercard; and the processor’s own markup. Flat-rate pricing folds all three into one number. Interchange-plus lists them separately. Subscription pricing adds a monthly fee in exchange for a thinner markup.

Merchant Account Fees & Pricing EXPLAINED: How to Lower Credit Card Processing Fees, PaymentCloud on YouTube

The three layers inside every fee

Interchange is the largest piece. Stripe’s explainer says it varies by card type, by whether the payment is online or in person, and by industry. A plain debit card and a premium rewards credit card therefore cost the processor different amounts for the same sale.

Debit is the one category where a federal ceiling exists. The Federal Reserve’s page on Regulation II states that a covered issuer may not receive more than $0.21 plus 0.05% of the transaction value, plus a $0.01 fraud-prevention adjustment where eligible. Issuers with less than $10 billion in assets are exempt, so the cap does not apply to every debit card a customer might hand over. The same page reports that covered transactions averaged $0.34 in interchange per transaction, or 0.73% of transaction value, in 2024 data.

The processor’s markup is the only layer negotiated between the business and the provider. Everything else is set elsewhere, which is why comparing quotes comes down to comparing markups and monthly charges.

Flat-rate pricing: one number, everything included

A flat rate charges the same percentage and per-transaction amount on every card of a given channel. Square’s pricing page, as listed on the page fetched on November 8, 2026, shows 2.6% + 15¢ for in-person payments on its free plan, 3.3% + 30¢ online, and 3.5% + 15¢ for keyed-in or card-on-file payments. Stripe’s pricing page lists 2.9% + 30¢ for domestic online cards and 2.7% + 5¢ for domestic cards on its in-person terminal, with add-ons: 0.5% more for manually entered cards, 1.5% more for international cards, and 1% more when currency conversion is needed.

Lightspeed’s guide to the subject lists the model’s strengths as simplicity and predictability, and its weaknesses as limited transparency and higher costs on cheaper transaction types. Stripe’s explainer makes the same point from the other side: a blended rate is set high enough to cover expensive cards, so a basic debit sale can pay more than it costs.

Where the flat rate earns its keep

The model suits a business with irregular volume. There is no monthly minimum on Square’s free tier, no statement to reconcile, and no setup beyond an application. Square’s page also notes that cash and check payments cost nothing. The full setup and fee walkthrough is in the earlier post on taking card payments with Square.

Where it costs more

Per-transaction cents matter most on small tickets. A 15¢ charge is 0.6% of a $25 sale and 0.15% of a $100 sale, so the effective rate on a snack or a single-item purchase sits well above the headline percentage.

Paper statements, a pen and a calculator on a small business desk.

Interchange-plus pricing: the cost passed through, the markup added

Interchange-plus bills the actual interchange and network cost of each transaction, then adds a fixed markup. Stripe’s explainer says the approach passes through the true cost of each transaction, and that it fits larger, higher-volume businesses better than small ones that want easy forecasting. The effective rate moves with the mix of cards presented, and statements run longer.

Helcim publishes its markup openly. As listed on the Helcim pricing page fetched November 8, 2026, the in-person markup is 0.40% + 8¢ for businesses processing up to $50,000 a month, falling to 0.35% + 7¢ from $50,000 to $100,000, 0.25% + 7¢ from $100,000 to $500,000, and lower above that. Keyed and online payments carry a higher markup (0.50% + 25¢ in the first tier). The page says volume discounts apply automatically using the last three months’ average, that there are no account monthly fees, and that interchange rates typically change twice a year, with the change passing through to the merchant.

Stripe’s pricing page lists IC+ pricing among custom packages for businesses with large payment volume or unusual business models, but publishes no rates, so a quote requires a conversation with sales. Square’s page mentions custom pricing for businesses that process over $250,000 a year and does not mention interchange-plus.

Not every interchange-plus quote is the same product. Lightspeed’s guide describes a third structure, tiered pricing, which sorts transactions into qualified, mid-qualified and non-qualified buckets with separate rates, and calls it the least transparent option. A quote that advertises the lowest bucket while placing most cards in a higher one defeats the purpose of shopping around, and asking for the rate on a regular rewards credit card, not the best-case debit card, exposes that.

Subscription pricing: a monthly fee in place of a fatter markup

Subscription, or membership, pricing charges a recurring fee and keeps the per-transaction markup low. Two published examples show two different shapes.

Square ties a lower flat rate to a paid software plan. Per its pricing page, the free plan costs $0 a month, Plus costs $49 a month per location and Premium costs $149 a month per location. In-person rates are 2.6% + 15¢, 2.5% + 15¢ and 2.4% + 15¢ respectively, and online rates are 3.3% + 30¢ on the free plan and 2.9% + 30¢ on the other two.

The arithmetic for in-person sales is direct. Moving from Free to Plus saves 0.1% of sales and costs $49, so the break-even is $49,000 a month in card sales at one location. Moving from Plus to Premium saves another 0.1% for $100 more, so that step breaks even at $100,000 a month. For online-only sales, Free to Plus saves 0.4%, which breaks even at $12,250 a month. These are the page’s rates run through division, and they ignore what the paid plans include beyond the processing discount. Square’s page says Plus includes POS features for every industry, so the real comparison also covers software the business would otherwise buy.

The second shape is the wholesale membership. A June 2023 Fit Small Business review of Payment Depot described a $79 monthly plan with a $250,000 annual processing limit, interchange plus 8¢ for card-present sales and plus 18¢ for card-not-present, and a $25 chargeback fee. That article is more than three years old, and Payment Depot’s own pricing page could not be fetched, so current terms must be confirmed with the company before any decision. The structure is the lesson: a fixed monthly charge replaces the percentage markup, which favors steady, higher volume and penalizes a slow month.

Three payment cards fanned out on a dark slate surface.

Putting dollar figures on it

The table uses a business taking $25 average in-person card sales. Interchange varies by card, so the example assumes an average interchange of 1.80% + 10¢ for the interchange-plus line. That assumption is illustrative only and is not a published rate. Network assessments and Stripe’s optional add-ons are left out.

Monthly card sales Square Free Square Plus Stripe Terminal Interchange-plus (assumed)
$10,000 (400 sales) $320 n/a $290 $292 (Helcim first-tier markup)
$60,000 (2,400 sales) $1,920 $1,909 $1,740 $1,698 (Helcim $50K-$100K markup)

At $10,000 the Plus plan is skipped because $49 cannot be recovered from a 0.1% discount. At $60,000 it roughly breaks even with the free plan. The lower per-transaction fee on Stripe’s terminal rate (5¢ against 15¢) explains much of its advantage on small tickets. With a $100 average ticket, the fixed-cents gap shrinks, and the percentages dominate.

Disputes sit outside these figures. Stripe’s page lists $15 per dispute received, and Helcim’s lists $15 for a chargeback lost and $0 for one resolved in the merchant’s favor. A refund does not always return the original fee either: Helcim’s page says the original processing fee is not returned on a refund. A refund policy that specifies when refunds are offered, such as the one covered in returns and refund policies for a small online shop, controls how often that cost is incurred.

Passing the cost to customers in New York

Some businesses respond to fees with a surcharge. New York regulates how. Erie County’s consumer protection office summarizes General Business Law section 518, as amended effective February 11, 2024: a business adding a surcharge must clearly and conspicuously post the highest total price for the transaction, inclusive of the surcharge, excluding sales tax. The surcharge cannot exceed the fee the card company charges the business, and the final price cannot exceed the posted price. The same page says a business may show both credit and cash prices or advertise a cash discount, but may not advertise that all prices include a cash discount that does not apply to credit card purchases. It lists fines of up to $500 per violation.

Card networks and processor agreements can add their own surcharge conditions, and those fall outside the sources fetched for this post. A processor’s contract is the place to check.

A laptop showing a blurred checkout page beside shipping boxes in a small shop's packing area.

Questions to put to any quote

A short list brings the three models onto the same footing.

  • What is the rate for a standard credit card, in person and online? The best-case debit rate says little.
  • Is there a monthly fee, a statement fee, a PCI fee, a minimum or an early cancellation charge? Helcim’s page lists none of these fees, which makes it a useful baseline when reading other quotes.
  • What does a chargeback cost, and is the fee returned when the dispute is won? Stripe returns the countered-dispute fee only on a win.
  • Does the rate change with monthly volume, and who decides? Helcim’s tiers adjust automatically from a three-month average.
  • How are keyed-in and card-on-file payments priced? Square lists 3.5% + 15¢ for both, above its in-person rate.

For a shop with a card reader on a counter, a low-volume online store and a mix of both, the answer often differs by channel. Online conversion also depends on the checkout itself, a subject covered in where small shops lose customers at checkout.

For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney, tax professional or financial advisor.

Sources

All pages fetched November 8, 2026.