Tips and Tip Pooling on a Restaurant POS in New York

Closed check presenter with folded bills and a pen on a restaurant table.

A restaurant point-of-sale system records every tip, and in New York the law decides what may happen to that money afterward. The state’s Department of Labor treats tips, service charges, pooling and the wage credit as separate subjects, and the IRS adds its own reporting layer on top. This article is general information drawn from agency pages fetched at the time of writing. It is not legal advice, and a restaurant with a specific pooling or payroll question needs an attorney or the Department of Labor.

Get Started with Toast Tips Manager, Toast, Inc. on YouTube

Tips and service charges are different things

The presumption that a charge is a tip

The New York Department of Labor’s tips and gratuities FAQ states that there is a rebuttable legal presumption that any charge not for food and drink is a tip. For banquets, special functions and package deals, an administration charge must be clearly labeled as such, and customers must be told it is not a gratuity or tip. The employer carries the burden of proving, by clear and convincing evidence, that a reasonable customer would understand the charge was not a tip.

The FAQ adds formatting detail: the notice appears in the contract and on menus and bills, in plain language and a font similar to the surrounding text, no smaller than 12-point. A delivery fee that the employer keeps in full needs a notice that the charge is not a tip and does not go to the delivery worker.

How the IRS sees the same money

The IRS draws a similar line on its tip recordkeeping and reporting page. Extra amounts charged to a bill, such as mandatory service charges, are not tips. Service charges are income to the employer whether or not they are passed along, and service charges distributed to employees must be treated as wages. A suggested percentage printed on a receipt is not a service charge when the customer can choose any amount or leave the line blank.

On a POS, the practical consequence is a category decision made in setup. A mandatory 20 percent charge for a large party belongs in a service charge line, and a tip prompt on the payment screen belongs in the tip line, because payroll and tax treatment differ for each.

The cash wage and the tip credit

Long Island rates

The Department of Labor’s minimum wage page lists the same figures for New York City, Long Island and Westchester. The general minimum is $17.00 an hour. Tipped service employees carry a $14.15 cash wage with a $2.85 tip credit, and tipped food service workers carry an $11.35 cash wage with a $5.65 tip credit. The page labels the table as effective January 1, 2027, and says the general rate will not rise on that date because an inflation-based condition has been met. Rates elsewhere in the state are lower, and the page states that only hospitality employers can apply the tip credit.

Limits on taking the credit

The tipped workers page says no tip credit may be taken for days when a tipped worker spends more than two hours, or twenty percent of a shift, on non-tipped work. Service employees must also reach weekly average tip thresholds; for restaurants in New York City, Long Island and Westchester the listed amount for 2027 is $3.65 an hour. Overtime is figured at time and a half of the minimum wage, minus the applicable tip credit.

The Department of Labor’s hospitality industry page works an example of the overtime math using a Long Island server in January 2022: $15.00 multiplied by 1.5 is $22.50, less a $5.00 tip credit, for $17.50. The figures are from 2022, and the page is cited here for the method.

For POS purposes the credit means that a clock-in record and a tips record have to line up by shift. The two-hour and twenty-percent limits mean time spent on non-tipped work has to be visible in the same records. The connection between scheduling and sales is covered in restaurant labor cost and scheduling against sales.

Handheld payment device on a restaurant table with a blurred tip screen.

Pooling and sharing under the hospitality rules

Two arrangements with different rules

The FAQ separates tip sharing from tip pooling. In tip sharing, directly tipped employees give part of their tips to other workers who provided direct customer service. In tip pooling, directly tipped employees contribute to a pool that is redistributed among directly and indirectly tipped employees.

Either arrangement can be voluntary or required. When the employer requires it, the employer may set the percentages among food service workers. When employees form it on their own, the employees set the percentages. The state’s regulation, 12 NYCRR 146-2.14 through 146-2.17, has separate sections for tip sharing, tip pooling and the records of each.

What employees cannot waive

The FAQ states that employees cannot agree to waive their legal protections over how tips are handled and paid. It also says an employer does not have to make up tips that a participant hides, with the example of a waiter who conceals a large cash tip. The hospitality page adds that records must be kept and made available for employees to review.

Credit card tips and the next payday

The FAQ requires employers to pay credit card tips no later than the next regularly scheduled payday. The employer may subtract the pro-rated share of the card company’s charge from the tip. The wage statement must show tips separately from wages.

A POS makes the pro-rated share arithmetic mechanical, because the total of card tips and the total of card processing charges both sit in the same sales data. The statement that reaches an employee should reconcile to the register report. Fees tied to card sales are discussed in taking card payments with Square.

Stack of cash, notebook and calculator on a restaurant back-office desk.

What the register can and cannot split

Square for Restaurants

Square’s tip-out guide says tips go directly to the team member who collected them by default. A pool is created under Staff, Settings, Tips in the Dashboard, and tips can be tallied per transaction, daily or weekly. They can be split equally or by fixed percentage, with recipients chosen by role.

Unassigned tips, such as those from transactions with no personal passcode, can be pooled equally across tip-eligible team members who clocked in that day. Two-step verification must be on before tipping out, and the feature requires a qualifying subscription such as Square for Restaurants Plus or Premium. Cash tip-outs run through the Pay In/Out function in Cash Management, labeled with the team member’s name and “Tips,” which creates a record separate from cash sales.

Toast

Toast’s tip pooling article describes tools outside Toast Tips Manager. Staff can declare negative cash tips to hand money to a busser or runner. A percentage tip-out by sales category appears on the shift review of the employee who distributes it, and Toast says it is not paid out automatically and must be dispersed by the restaurant’s staff.

The Pooled Tips report is the most easily misread of the group. Toast states that the system does not actually pool tips and pay them out; the report only shows a suggested split among servers, based on hours worked, over a date range limited to two weeks. Toast also says it does not report tip-out transfers per employee in Labor Summary, so printed shift reviews should be kept if a record is needed. Toast treats its separate Tips Manager product as a different tool, and the article defers to that product’s own guide for anyone using it.

The difference between “suggests a split” and “executes a split” matters under New York’s recordkeeping rules, which require an accounting of tips collected and distributed through any pool or share.

Federal reporting that follows the tips

Employee reports and withholding

The IRS Topic 761 page says employees who receive $20 or more in cash tips in a calendar month must report the total to the employer in writing by the tenth day of the following month. The employer uses the report to calculate Social Security, Medicare and income tax withholding on wages and reported tips, and pays the employer’s share of Social Security and Medicare tax. The tip recordkeeping page adds that tips received through a tip pool count as tip income for the recipient, and that employers must retain employee tip reports.

Form 8027 for larger operations

The instructions for Form 8027 require an employer operating a large food or beverage establishment to file the form, with each qualifying location getting its own. A large establishment is one that normally employed more than 10 employees on a typical business day in the preceding year. If reported tips fall below 8 percent of gross receipts, the employer allocates the difference to directly tipped employees, and allocated tips appear in box 8 of the Form W-2. For the current cycle the instructions give March 1, 2027 for paper filing and March 31, 2027 for electronic filing.

Paper staff schedule with pencil marks, coffee cup and reading glasses on a wooden table.

Records and notices that need to exist

The Department of Labor FAQ lists four things a hospitality employer keeps: an accounting of all tips collected and distributed through any pool or share, an accounting of any tip credit taken, an accounting of any tip paid through a paycheck, and the written notice to each employee about the intent to take a tip credit. Records apply however tips arrive, tip jars included. The notice has to be given at or before hiring.

The hospitality page sets a six-year retention period for wage records, including tip credits. A POS export saved on the same schedule as payroll records gives the restaurant a second copy of the tip data, and the general retention question is addressed in what records a small business keeps and for how long. The first-hire side of the paperwork, including the pay notice, is covered in hiring a first employee in New York.

This article is general information, not legal or tax advice. Pooling structures, service charge wording and tip credit eligibility turn on facts that vary from one restaurant to the next.

For informational purposes only — consult a licensed attorney, tax professional or financial advisor.

Sources

All pages fetched at the time of writing.